Bitcoin miners are facing a critical survival test as mining costs approach unsustainable levels. When Bitcoin’s price falls below the electricity cost threshold, machines shutting down could reduce selling pressure and trigger a price rebound. However, with the emergence of next-generation, high-efficiency miners, the role of the shutdown price is changing. The long-held belief that “shutdowns lead to rebounds” may no longer hold. Moving forward, Bitcoin’s price movements will be shaped more by technological advancements, macroeconomic shifts, and market sentiment.

Deep in the night, the relentless hum of mining machines fills the air, like an endless symphony of computation. But as Bitcoin fluctuates around $85,000, a hidden tension grips the mining farms—over half of the machines are on the brink of shutdown, facing a harsh dilemma: keep burning electricity to stay operational or cut losses and power down? This silent battle underscores a fundamental rule of the crypto market—the shutdown price. Once seen as a reliable bottom signal, it is now being challenged by the rapid evolution of mining technology. Can Bitcoin still depend on the shutdown price to stage a comeback? The answer lies in the ongoing battle between mining efficiency and cost structures.

Shutdown Price: The Lifeline of Bitcoin Miners

In Bitcoin’s digital economy, miners are the backbone, relying on computational power to sustain their operations, while electricity is their essential fuel. The shutdown price is like their minimum oxygen level—when Bitcoin’s price drops below this threshold, mining revenue no longer covers electricity costs, leaving miners with no option but to power down their rigs.

Precise Calculation Formula for Shutdown Price:

Shutdown Price = (Daily Power Consumption of Miner × Electricity Price) ÷ (Daily Bitcoin Output × Mining Pool Fee Factor)

For example, the Antminer S19 consumes 72 kWh daily (electricity price at $0.06 per kWh) and produces approximately 0.0002 BTC per day. This calculates to a shutdown price of around $85,000, aligning closely with the current market price. This is not a coincidence but rather a reflection of half the industry hanging by a thread.

However, the shutdown price is never a static number. It fluctuates as miners relocate to areas with cheaper electricity, moves in sync with Bitcoin’s difficulty adjustments, and continuously reshapes under the impact of new-generation mining machines. Like a dynamic dance, when old machines shut down, the overall network hashrate declines, giving survivors a chance to breathe and recover. Every two weeks, difficulty adjustments act like a conductor’s baton, ensuring a steady block production rhythm. Meanwhile, next-gen miners like the Antminer S21 XP emerge, reducing electricity costs to 35% and shifting the industry’s cost baseline downward. It is the interplay of these factors that makes the shutdown price a hidden compass for identifying market bottoms.

Historical Code: Shutdown Price and Its Role in Bitcoin Rebounds

Flipping through Bitcoin’s historical records, shutdown price appears to be a hidden beacon—every time Bitcoin’s price touches this threshold, the market seems to find a turning point.

December 2018

• Bitcoin plummeted from $20,000 to $3,150.
• Bitmain’s Antminer S9 miners (shutdown price around $3,500) shut down on a large scale.
• Six months later, Bitcoin rebounded to $14,000, marking a 344% increase.

March 2020

• “Black Thursday” saw Bitcoin’s price halved to $3,800.
• Total network hashrate dropped by 30% due to miner shutdowns.
• After the shutdown wave, Bitcoin entered a historic bull run, soaring to $65,000 within 15 months.

2022 Bear Market

• When Bitcoin fell below $20,000, publicly traded North American mining companies were forced to sell their Bitcoin reserves to cover electricity costs.
• However, as hashrate dropped by 26%, Bitcoin rebounded at the start of 2023.

2022 Bear Market

• When Bitcoin fell below $20,000, publicly traded North American mining companies were forced to sell their Bitcoin reserves to cover electricity costs.
• However, as hashrate dropped by 26%, Bitcoin rebounded at the start of 2023.

Why Has “Shutdown Means Bottom” Always Worked?

The key lies in the self-correcting mechanisms of the Bitcoin mining ecosystem:

• Miners sell approximately 900 BTC daily to cover electricity costs.
• A shutdown wave eliminates this sell pressure, creating a supply-side shock.
• Institutional investors see shutdown price as a cost floor, leading to buying pressure at these levels.
• Mining difficulty adjustments act like a spring—the deeper it is compressed, the stronger the rebound potential.

However, this once-reliable playbook is now facing uncertainty under the shadow of new mining technology.

Mining Machine Evolution: The Breaker of the Shutdown Price Curse?

As the Antminer S21 XP drives the shutdown price down to $29,757, while the outdated Whatsminer M30S+ struggles to survive near $85,000, a “hashrate Darwinism” survival race is underway. From the Antminer S9 (28nm chips, 100J/TH efficiency) in 2016 to the S21 XP (5nm chips, 15J/TH efficiency) in 2024, mining efficiency has increased nearly sevenfold in eight years, marking a leap akin to the transition from steam engines to maglev trains. New-generation miners not only operate at lower costs but also push older models out of the market with their sheer computational power. According to estimates by the Cambridge Centre for Blockchain Research, once S21 models account for 20% of the total network hashrate, the average shutdown price could drop by 40%. This raises an intriguing question: If the shutdown price falls to $30,000 while Bitcoin fluctuates between $40,000 and $60,000, will the classic “shutdown-triggered rebound” still hold true?

The impact of this mining arms race extends beyond just numbers. Morgan Stanley analysts pointed out in a report:

“Improvements in mining efficiency are reshaping Bitcoin’s cost curve, compressing the shutdown price range from tens of thousands of dollars to just a few thousand.”

At the same time, large-scale mining farms are increasingly hedging their profits via futures contracts and securing cheap electricity, further weakening the significance of shutdown prices. The historical shutdown-price-triggered rebound pattern seems to be quietly dismantled by technology and capital forces.

The Crossroads of Shutdown Price: Rebound or Silence?

The future of Bitcoin’s shutdown price has divided the market into two camps:

• The “Ineffectiveness” Camp argues that hardware advancements have outpaced Bitcoin price fluctuations, making shutdown price increasingly irrelevant as a market anchor. Additionally, the rise of Bitcoin spot ETFs has blurred the connection between miner selling pressure and price action.
• The “Evolution” Camp believes that hardware efficiency will eventually hit a physical limit (approaching 1nm chip fabrication), while rising global electricity costs—especially under carbon neutrality policies—will offset gains in efficiency.

According to CoinMetrics:

• The global Bitcoin mining market hit $5 billion in 2023, up 25% year-over-year.
• Meanwhile, electricity costs have risen 15% over the past five years.

No matter which side is right, shutdown price is evolving:

• Its influence is narrowing
• Rebound cycles have shortened from months to weeks
• “Super miners” with cutting-edge rigs and cheap electricity are taking over

Can Bitcoin Still Rely on Shutdown Price for a Rebound?

At $86,900, the answer is uncertain.

Shutdown price has historically signaled market bottoms and fueled price rebounds. But today, it faces new challenges:

• If Bitcoin drops further, newer rigs (e.g., Antminer S21 XP, shutdown price ~$29,757) will likely stay operational, while older rigs shutting down could ease selling pressure, attract investors, and trigger a small recovery.
• If Bitcoin consolidates between $80,000 and $90,000, shutdown price may lose its traditional significance, leaving Bitcoin’s trajectory increasingly driven by macroeconomic trends and market sentiment.

BitMEX founder Arthur Hayes put it succinctly:

“Don’t expect shutdown price to save the market like before. Future volatility will come from external capital flows.”

Market Signals Suggest a Mixed Outlook

• Bitcoin has suffered its steepest three-day drop (-15%) since the FTX collapse.
• 10x Research founder Markus Thielen warned in a report:
  • In a worst-case scenario, Bitcoin could drop to $72,000–$74,000 before rebounding.
  • Short-term holder realized price (average purchase price of BTC held for less than 155 days) is currently around $82,000.
  • Historically, Bitcoin rarely falls below this level during bull markets but can struggle to regain it in bear markets.

Thielen also pointed out:

• Bitcoin’s correlation with global central bank liquidity has a delayed effect—if liquidity tightens further, downward pressure may intensify.
• However, the $82,000 level could serve as key support, potentially setting the stage for a rebound.

Final Thoughts: Lessons from the Hashrate Jungle

For the average investor, the evolution of shutdown price is a valuable survival lesson. When the market cheers “shutdown price reached”, don’t forget to check the leading mining rigs and their share of the total hashrate. Financial reports from major mining firms like Marathon and Riot can reveal hidden signs of selling pressure—for example, their inventory-to-debt ratio. More importantly, shutdown price is not a crystal ball, but rather an X-ray of the market ecosystem, reflecting the interplay of hashrate, cost efficiency, and human behavior. Just as Bitcoin’s network always follows the longest chain, shutdown price will continue to evolve alongside miners’ profit-seeking strategies and technological advancements. A rebound may no longer be guaranteed, but the adventure in the hashrate jungle is far from over.

This mining arms race is not just about numbers. A Morgan Stanley analyst once noted in a report: “Improvements in mining efficiency are reshaping Bitcoin’s cost structure. The shutdown price range may compress from thousands of dollars to just a few thousand.” At the same time, large-scale mining farms are securing profits through futures hedging and low-cost electricity, further weakening shutdown price’s significance. The historical “shutdown price effect”, once seen as a near-magical market indicator, now appears to be gradually unraveling under the forces of technology and capital.

Disclaimer：

1. This article is reposted from [MarsBit], with copyright belonging to the original author [Luke, Mars Finance]. If there are any objections to this reposting, please contact the Gate Learn team, and the team will handle the matter promptly according to relevant procedures.
2. Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article represent only the author’s personal views and do not constitute any investment advice.
3. Other language versions of this article have been translated by the Gate Learn Team. Unless explicitly mentioned in connection with Gate.io, reproduction, distribution, or plagiarism of the translated content is not permitted.